Abstract
A Study on Development of Closed Laddering
Technique Using Software and Application to Advertising Strategy
| |
|
| |
Song, Gee-In |
| |
Department of Journalism and Communication Studies
|
| |
The Graduate School of Kyung Hee University |
Modern society has been becoming more complex. And that situation
have been laying in marketing and advertising area. In today's environment,
the consumers are also getting sophisticated. So, marketers are
facing many difficulties in understanding consumers' decision in
marketing. In this trend, some researchers have been interested
in the theory related to consumer decision. That is Means-end chain
theory. Especially, the focus of this theory is value and cognitive
structure which consumers have in the relation with product or brand.
Means-end chain theroy is and umbrella term that refers to a set
of methods for interviewing consumers about the reasons for their
decision choice and interpreting consumer's responses in terms of
linkages between outcomes(Olson an Reynlods, 2001). And, in th most
general means-end formulation, consumers have three levels of product-related
knowledge-product attributes, the consequences or outcomes of using
a product, and the broad goals or values that may be satisfied by
use of that product.
To research consumer's means-end chain in marketing situation the
researchers have to use the tool of research like laddering interview.
Therefore, the laddering interview is the preferred method for indentifying
consumers' means-end chains. Actually, laddering is a method in
which respondents describe, freely in their own words, why something
is important to them. The qualitative nature of laddering derives
from th open-ended response format.
But, sometimes, the features of this open-ended laddering has brought
about some pracitcal problems in research methods: (1) the significant
time and cost of gathering individal in-depth, means-end(laddering)
data; (2) the time and effort required to perform the content analysis
of the qualitative responses(steps in the ladders) and the quantitative
summaries of the dominant pathways: (3) the lack of any detailed
framework or system to translate strategic options as represented
in the summary Hierarchical Value Map into a working format for
the agency creative staff.
In this point, the purpose of this study is to develop a new closed
laddering, using software in on-line, and applying it to marketing
and advertising strategy. That is, the development and practical
use of a new laddering technique is to overcome the problems of
open-ended laddering and contribute to the prosperity of means-end
chain theory.
After reviewing the literature and considering research purpose,
the following research questions are established.
Research Question ¥°: Do the closed laddering using software have
the validity in comparing to the open-ended laddering?
Research Question ¥±: How can the closed laddering using software
be used in the practical area in means-end chain theory?
RQ ¥±-1: What is the Hierarchical Value Map of consumers in brands
researched with the colsed laddering using software?
RQ ¥±-2: How can the Hierarchical Value Map of consumers researched
with the colsed laddering using software be applied into developing
advertising strategy?
A new closed laddering software was developed and used for 155
samples of university and college students and empirical data of
it was collected and analyzed by SPSS(11.0).
The research results are as follows. First, the frequency order
of relations between the open-ended laddering items and software
closed laddering items is almost consistent among each levels(attribute-functional
consequence-psychological consequence-value) on Hierarchical Value
Map. So, the software closed laddering is testified to have the
validity in methodology.
Secondly, applied in the results form using software colsed laddering,
the Hierarchical Value Map of consumers for 4 brands such as Anycall,
Giodano, Krinex, and Minishell is significantly analysed through
frequency and correlation analysis among each items of levels(attribute-functional
consequence -psychological consequence-value). It means the software
closed laddering has the efficiency in applying it to practical
use.
Lastly, the application in advertising strategy development which
the results of Hierarchical Value Map of consumers for 4 brands
are substituted for is proved to have the efficiency. Especially,
the results of advertising strategy for 4 brands was different from
the subjects' sex. And driving force(value) in 4 brands was almost
same. That means the respondents have the same ends. In applying
to advertising strategy, it is supported that the software closed
laddering has the efficiency.
Although the newly developed software closed laddering has the
validity in methodology and efficiency in applying to practice,
there are some limitations in this study. Firstly, the research
sample was limited to university and college students, so the result
of this study could not be generalized. Secondly, the fixed depth
response form consumers. Thirdly, although this study use the variable
like sex in demographics, this study has the limitation in not applying
some various variables to this research. Lastly, because the value
items in using the software closed laddering was restricted to the
personal values' items, this study has the limitation not to constitute
other various value items.
|